Bare Tool vs Battery and Charger Included Reciprocating Saws: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you compare a bare tool vs battery and charger included reciprocating saw, you are weighing convenience against existing gear compatibility. Both the DEWALT DCS382B and the CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 are 20V cordless options designed for demolition and cutting tasks. They share a brushless motor design and variable speed triggers. The primary difference lies in what arrives in the box. One kit includes the battery and charger, while the other requires you to supply your own power source.
Key differences
| Aspect | DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw | Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Battery Included | Bare Tool | Battery and Charger Included |
| Stroke Length | 1-1/8 in. | 1-in |
| Motor Type | Brushless | Brushless |
| Blade Clamp | Twist-style keyless | Tool-Free release |
| Tool Length | Not listed | 14.5-in |
| Max Speed | Not listed | 3,000 RPM |
Which one should you choose?
Choose DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw if
- You already own compatible 20V batteries and want to save money on redundant gear.
- You prefer a longer stroke length for faster cutting through thicker materials.
- You want a twist-style clamp for quick blade changes without removing your hand.
Choose Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit if
- You need a complete kit with the battery and charger included for immediate use.
- You value a specified maximum speed of 3,000 RPM for rapid cutting.
- You prefer a tool-free blade release system for faster swap times.
Verdict: Choose the DEWALT if you already have batteries and need a longer stroke for aggressive cutting. Pick the CRAFTSMAN if you want a ready-to-use kit with a tool-free blade clamp and known high-speed performance.
Bare Tool vs Kit Recip Saws
Included accessories
The CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 is a complete kit that includes both the battery and the charger. You get everything needed to start working immediately without buying separate components. The DEWALT DCS382B is sold as a bare tool. It does not include a battery or charger. This option is better if you already own compatible 20V MAX batteries and chargers from the same brand. You save money by reusing existing gear. If you lack DEWALT batteries, you must purchase them separately. The CRAFTSMAN kit offers immediate readiness for users starting fresh.
Motor type
Both the DEWALT DCS382B and the CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 feature brushless motors. This specification indicates that neither tool uses carbon brushes to commutate the motor. Brushless designs generally offer longer life and reduced maintenance compared to brushed alternatives. They also provide better efficiency and runtime on a single charge. Since both products utilize this technology, there is no significant difference in the core drive mechanism based on the provided data. You get similar efficiency benefits from either choice regarding the motor construction.
Stroke length
The DEWALT DCS382B has a stroke length of 1-1/8 inches. The CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 has a stroke length of 1 inch. A longer stroke length typically allows the saw to remove more material per stroke. This can lead to faster cutting speeds in softer materials or thicker stock. The DEWALT option provides a slightly larger stroke. This might offer a marginal advantage in cutting speed for heavy-duty demolition tasks. The difference is small, but the DEWALT specification is numerically higher.
Speed control
The CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 specifies a maximum speed of 3,000 RPM. It also features a full variable speed trigger. This allows you to adjust the speed precisely for different materials. The DEWALT DCS382B lists a 2-finger variable trigger but does not state the maximum RPM in the provided data. Both tools offer variable speed control for better handling. However, the CRAFTSMAN provides a specific top speed figure. This clarity helps you gauge performance potential for high-speed cutting applications.
Blade clamp
The DEWALT DCS382B uses a twist-style keyless blade clamp. You change blades by twisting the mechanism. The CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 uses a tool-free blade release. Both methods allow for quick blade changes without additional tools. The keyless design on the DEWALT is a twist action. The CRAFTSMAN release is described as tool-free. Both systems prioritize ease of use and speed when swapping blades. Neither option requires a wrench or screwdriver for blade changes. The mechanism type differs slightly, but both serve the same practical function.
Tool length
The CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 has a specified tool length of 14.5 inches. The DEWALT DCS382B is described as having a compact size but does not list a specific length in the data. A shorter tool can be easier to maneuver in tight spaces. The CRAFTSMAN provides a clear dimension for planning workspace requirements. The DEWALT is noted for seamless mobility and a high range of motion. Without a specific measurement, it is hard to compare the exact footprint. The CRAFTSMAN length is explicitly stated.
Choose Your Reciprocating Saw Based On Needs
You already own compatible 20V batteries
The DEWALT DCS382B is a bare tool, meaning you already have the power source. Its brushless motor offers optimized cutting efficiency for demanding tasks. The 1-1/8 inch stroke length provides rapid material removal. You get a compact design for high range of motion in tight spaces.
You need a complete ready-to-use kit
The CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 includes both battery and charger, so you can start working immediately. It features a full variable speed trigger for precise control up to 3,000 RPM. The tool-free blade release speeds up changes. The contoured over-molded handle adds comfort during extended use sessions.
You prioritize maximum stroke length
The DEWALT DCS382B has a 1-1/8 inch stroke length, which is longer than the CRAFTSMAN's 1-inch stroke. This allows for faster cutting through various materials. The 2-finger variable trigger offers ease of use. You benefit from the stout brushless motor for consistent power delivery during heavy-duty demolition work.
You want tool-free blade changes
The CRAFTSMAN CMCS300M1 uses a tool-free blade release system for quick swaps. This contrasts with the DEWALT's twist-style keyless clamp. The kit includes a battery and charger for immediate use. Its 14.5-inch length is designed for cutting in tight spaces, offering added control with a full variable speed trigger.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw | Existing DEWALT 20V battery owners | Check price of DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw on Amazon |
| 2 | Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit | users wanting a complete battery and charger kit | Check price of Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit on Amazon |
The products compared
DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw
Best for: Existing DEWALT 20V battery owners
- Battery Included
- Bare Tool (what this guide is about)
- Power Source
- 20V MAX
- Stroke Length
- 1-1/8 in.
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Blade Clamp
- Keyless, twist-style
- Variable Speed Trigger
- 2-finger variable trigger
View on Amazon: DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
This is a bare-tool reciprocating saw designed for users who already own compatible 20V MAX batteries. It features a brushless motor for efficient cutting and a 1-1/8 inch stroke length for rapid material removal. The 2-finger variable trigger allows for speed control, while the compact body aids mobility in tight spaces. You get quick blade changes via a twist-style clamp, but you must supply your own power source.
Pros
- Brushless motor for optimized cutting efficiency
- 1-1/8 inch stroke length for fast cuts
- 2-finger variable trigger for speed control
- Twist-style keyless blade clamp for quick changes
Cons
- Sold as a bare tool with no battery included
- No charger included in the package
- Requires separate purchase of 20V MAX battery
Good fit if
- You already own DEWALT 20V MAX batteries
- You want to save weight and cost by reusing existing power sources
- You need a compact tool for tight spaces
Skip if
- You do not own compatible 20V batteries
- You need a complete kit ready to use immediately
- You want a tool with a built-in battery
Verdict: DEWALT 20V XR Brushless Recip Saw is a practical option for existing DEWALT 20V users who want to expand their tool lineup without buying redundant batteries. It fits pros and DIYers who prioritize motor efficiency and compact design over all-in-one convenience.
Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit
Best for: users wanting a complete battery and charger kit
- Battery Included
- Battery and Charger Included (what this guide is about)
- Power Source
- V20 Cordless
- Stroke Length
- 1-in
- Strokes Per Minute
- 3,000 RPM
- Tool Length
- 14.5-in
- Blade Clamp
- Tool-Free blade release
View on Amazon: Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit Affiliate link
This Craftsman V20 reciprocating saw kit includes the battery and charger, so you can start working immediately. It delivers up to 3,000 RPM with a 1-inch stroke length for efficient cutting. The 14.5-inch tool length helps you reach into tight spaces. A full variable speed trigger gives you control over the cutting pace. The contoured handle adds comfort during extended use.
Pros
- Battery and charger included for immediate use
- Full variable speed trigger up to 3,000 RPM
- 1-inch stroke length for speed
- Tool-free blade release for quick changes
- Compact 14.5-inch tool length
Cons
- Heavier at 7.06 pounds than bare tools
- Single speed setting without electronic controls
- No brushless motor specified in data
Good fit if
- You need a complete kit without buying parts separately
- You work in tight spaces requiring a short tool
- You prefer variable speed control for different materials
Skip if
- You already own compatible V20 batteries and want to save weight
- You require a brushless motor for longer runtime
- You need a lighter tool for overhead work
Verdict: Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit suits buyers who want a ready-to-use package with variable speed control. It is ideal for general demolition where the included battery and charger simplify the process.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw | Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Power Source | 20V MAX | V20 Cordless |
| Stroke Length | 1-1/8 in. | 1-in |
| Strokes Per Minute | not stated | 3,000 RPM |
| Motor Type | Brushless | not stated |
| Battery Included | Tool Only | Battery and Charger Included |
| Tool Length | not stated | 14.5-in |
| Blade Clamp | Keyless, twist-style | Tool-Free blade release |
| Variable Speed Trigger | 2-finger variable trigger | Full variable speed trigger |
| Voltage | 20V | 20V |
| Included Tools | Reciprocating Saw | Reciprocating Saw |
| Wheel Diameter | not stated | 5 Inch |
| Dimensions | not stated | 15.3 × 4 × 7.25 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 7.06 pounds |
| Color | Black | Red, Black |
| Model | not stated | CMCS300M1 |
Frequently asked questions
Does a bare tool reciprocating saw include a battery?
No, a bare tool reciprocating saw does not include a battery. You must purchase compatible batteries separately. The DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw is sold as a bare tool. This option is practical if you already own DEWALT 20V batteries. It allows you to expand your tool lineup without buying redundant power sources.
What does a battery and charger included kit provide?
A battery and charger included kit provides a complete, ready-to-use package. You receive the saw along with the necessary battery and charger. The Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit includes both components. This setup simplifies the process for general demolition tasks by eliminating the need to buy separate accessories.
Is the DEWALT saw brushless or brushed?
The DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw features a brushless motor. Brushless motors offer optimized cutting efficiency and longer runtime. This design is ideal for demanding tasks where motor efficiency matters. It fits users who prioritize performance and compact design over all-in-one convenience.
Does the Craftsman saw come with a battery?
Yes, the Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit includes a battery. The package also comes with a charger. This makes it suitable for users wanting a complete kit. You get everything needed to start working immediately without purchasing additional components separately.
Which saw is better for existing DEWALT users?
The DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw is better for existing DEWALT users. It is designed for those who already own DEWALT 20V batteries. Buying the bare tool avoids redundant battery purchases. It allows you to add a new tool to your existing ecosystem efficiently.
Does the Craftsman saw have variable speed control?
Yes, the Craftsman V20 3000 RPM Reciprocating Saw Kit offers variable speed control. This feature allows you to adjust the cutting speed based on the material. It suits buyers who need flexibility for general demolition tasks. The included battery and charger make it a ready-to-use package.
Are both saws cordless?
Yes, both the DEWALT and Craftsman saws are cordless. They operate on 20V battery power. This provides mobility and eliminates cord management during use. You can cut in various locations without being tethered to an outlet.