Looking Beyond the Makita XRJ05Z 18V LXT Lithium-Ion? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You might be looking for makita xrj05z 18v lxt lithium ion alternatives if the standard reciprocating saw does not fit your specific workflow. The Makita XRJ05Z delivers high cutting speed with its brushless motor, offering up to 3,000 strokes per minute on the high setting. It features a tool-less blade change system and a compact 17-1/4 inch length. However, it weighs 8.2 pounds with a battery, which may cause fatigue during extended overhead use. Some users prefer a lighter, one-handed design for tight spaces, while others might already own batteries from a different brand ecosystem.
The 6 alternatives listed here were chosen because their core specifications overlap with the original tool. You will find options that share the brushless motor type and cordless power source, ensuring comparable efficiency. The list includes subcompact models that weigh as little as 3.9 pounds, addressing the weight concern. Other picks offer different voltage platforms like 20V or 18V HP, catering to users who need to stick with existing battery packs. Each option is evaluated on how its specs, such as stroke rate, tool length, and weight, compare to the Makita baseline, helping you select the tool that best matches your physical needs and power system.
Our top pick: Makita 18V LXT Brushless Reciprocating Saw.
How each alternative compares
Makita 18V Brushless One-Handed Reciprocating Saw
The Makita XRJ08Z is a one-handed reciprocating saw designed for tight spaces and overhead cuts. It is significantly shorter at 14.4 inches compared to the XRJ05Z’s 17.25 inches. The XRJ08Z is also lighter, weighing just 1 pound with a battery, whereas the XRJ05Z weighs 8.2 pounds. Both tools use the 18V LXT system and feature brushless motors. The XRJ08Z prioritizes maneuverability and reduced fatigue in confined areas. You should choose this model if you need a compact, one-handed tool for detailed demolition work. It sacrifices the longer stroke and higher speed of the XRJ05Z for better control in tight spots.
RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Reciprocating Saw
The RYOBI PBLRS02B offers high-speed cutting with a brushless motor, similar to the Makita XRJ05Z. However, it is part of the RYOBI ONE+ HP system, so it requires RYOBI batteries rather than Makita 18V LXT packs. The RYOBI saw is slightly longer at 19.2 inches and lighter at 7.2 pounds compared to the Makita’s 17.25-inch length and 8.2-pound weight. Both are bare tools. The RYOBI model emphasizes surface protection and durability for demanding tasks. You should pick this alternative if you already own RYOBI batteries and need a robust tool for heavy-duty cutting. It provides comparable performance but fits a different battery ecosystem.
RIDGID 18V Subcompact Brushless One-Hand Reciprocating Saw
The RIDGID R8648B is a subcompact, one-handed reciprocating saw built for tight spaces. It is much shorter at 14.5 inches and significantly lighter at 3.9 pounds compared to the XRJ05Z’s 17.25-inch length and 8.2-pound weight. Like the Makita, it uses an 18V battery system, though the specific brand ecosystem differs. The RIDGID model is designed for lightweight handling and one-handed operation. You should choose this tool if you need a compact option for demolition work where maneuverability is key. It gives up the longer stroke and higher speed of the XRJ05Z in favor of a smaller footprint and reduced weight.
DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw
The DEWALT DCS382B is a 20V MAX brushless reciprocating saw designed for rapid demolition. It operates on the DEWALT 20V MAX platform, so it is not compatible with Makita 18V LXT batteries. The tool is compact and efficient for contractors who already own DEWALT batteries. Specific dimensions and weight are not provided in the data, but it is positioned as a compact alternative. You should consider this model if you are invested in the DEWALT ecosystem and need a reliable tool for fast cutting. It offers similar brushless performance but requires switching to a different battery system.
DEWALT 20V MAX XR Compact Reciprocating Saw
The DEWALT DCS367B is a 20V MAX XR compact reciprocating saw that includes a built-in work light. This feature aids visibility in dark or tight spaces, which the Makita XRJ05Z does not have. The DEWALT saw is shorter at 14.5 inches and lighter at 5.4 pounds compared to the Makita’s 17.25-inch length and 8.2-pound weight. It uses the DEWALT 20V MAX battery system. You should choose this model if you need a compact tool with enhanced visibility for detailed work. It offers a different battery ecosystem and includes a practical light feature for better performance in low-light conditions.
Milwaukee M18 Fuel Brushless Reciprocating Saw
The Milwaukee 2821-20 is an M18 Fuel brushless reciprocating saw focused on durability and a secure blade clamp. It uses the Milwaukee M18 battery system, so it is not compatible with Makita 18V LXT packs. The tool is shorter at 10 inches and lighter at 6.8 pounds compared to the XRJ05Z’s 17.25-inch length and 8.2-pound weight. Milwaukee emphasizes durability and a robust clamp mechanism. You should pick this alternative if you already own M18 batteries and prioritize a secure blade hold and durable construction. It sacrifices the Makita’s longer reach for a more compact and durable design.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Makita 18V LXT Brushless Reciprocating Saw
Best for: Makita ecosystem users needing high speed
- Power Source
- 18V
- Stroke Length
- 1-1/4"
- Strokes Per Minute
- 0-2, 300 (low) & 0-3, 000 (high) SPM
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Included
- Tool only
- Tool Weight
- 7.8 pounds
View on Amazon: Makita 18V LXT Brushless Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
The Makita XRJ05Z is a cordless reciprocating saw powered by an 18V LXT lithium-ion battery. It features a brushless motor that delivers 0-3,000 strokes per minute. The tool measures 17-1/4 inches long and weighs 8.2 lbs with a battery. It includes a tool-less blade change system for quick swaps. This model suits users who need a compact, high-speed cutting tool for various demolition or pruning tasks.
Pros
- Brushless motor provides 0-3,000 strokes per minute
- Tool-less blade change system for fast installation
- Compact 17-1/4 inch length reduces fatigue
- Variable speed trigger offers precise control
Cons
- Sold as a bare tool without battery or charger
- Heavier at 8.2 lbs compared to subcompact rivals
- Only includes one 6-inch 6TPI blade
Good fit if
- You already own Makita 18V LXT batteries
- You need a compact saw for tight spaces
- You prefer a tool-less blade change system
Skip if
- You need a complete kit with battery and charger
- You require a subcompact one-handed design
- You want a lighter tool under 8 lbs
Verdict: Makita 18V LXT Brushless Reciprocating Saw fits professionals who already use the 18V LXT system and need a reliable, high-stroke-rate tool for general cutting. It is less suitable for users seeking a lighter, one-handed subcompact option.
Makita 18V Brushless One-Handed Reciprocating Saw
Best for: One-handed cutting in tight spaces with existing 18V batteries
- Power Source
- 18V LXT
- Stroke Length
- 7/8 in.
- Strokes Per Minute
- 0-3,100 SPM
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Included
- Tool Only
- Tool Length
- 14.4 inches
View on Amazon: Makita 18V Brushless One-Handed Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
This is the Makita XRJ08Z, an 18V LXT brushless reciprocating saw designed for one-handed operation. It reaches 3,100 strokes per minute with a 7/8-inch stroke length. The tool weighs 1 pound and measures 14.4 inches in length. Its loop-shaped handle guard adds rigidity. You get a tool-only unit without a battery. This compact design suits users needing reduced vibration and faster cutting speeds in tight spaces.
Pros
- Brushless motor delivers up to 3,100 strokes per minute
- 7/8-inch stroke length allows for faster cutting
- One-handed grip design reduces vibration by up to 40%
- Loop-shaped handle guard improves tool rigidity
- Compact 14.4-inch length fits tight spaces
Cons
- Sold as a bare tool without a battery
- Heavier than subcompact one-handed alternatives
- Limited to 18V LXT platform compatibility
Good fit if
- You need a one-handed saw for overhead or tight work
- You already own Makita 18V LXT batteries
- You prioritize reduced vibration during extended use
Skip if
- You require a complete kit with battery and charger
- You prefer a two-handed grip for maximum stability
- You need a 20V MAX or M18 platform tool
Verdict: Makita 18V Brushless One-Handed Recip Saw offers high speed and low vibration for users already invested in the 18V LXT ecosystem. It is ideal for professionals who need a compact, one-handed tool for tight spaces and overhead cuts.
RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Reciprocating Saw
Best for: high-speed cutting and surface protection
- Power Source
- 18V Cordless
- Stroke Length
- 1-1/4"
- Strokes Per Minute
- 0-3,200 SPM
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Included
- Tool only
- Tool Weight
- 7.2 pounds
View on Amazon: RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
The RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Recip Saw delivers high performance with a 0-3,200 SPM stroke rate and a 1-1/4 inch stroke length. Its brushless motor supports up to 470 cuts per charge. The tool-free blade release lever and variable speed trigger offer precise control. This 7.2-pound saw includes a pivoting shoe and LED light for better visibility and surface protection.
Pros
- Brushless motor provides up to 470 cuts per charge
- 0-3,200 SPM stroke rate for aggressive cutting
- Tool-free blade release lever for quick changes
- Non-marring pivoting shoe protects surfaces
Cons
- Heavier at 7.2 pounds compared to compact alternatives
- Longer 19.2-inch length reduces maneuverability in tight spaces
- Bare tool requires separate battery purchase
Good fit if
- You need high cutting speed for aggressive jobs
- You prefer a pivoting shoe for surface protection
- You already own RYOBI 18V batteries
Skip if
- You require a one-handed compact design
- You need a lighter tool for overhead work
- You want a shorter tool for tight spaces
Verdict: RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Recip Saw suits users prioritizing cutting speed and surface protection over compact size. It fits those who already have RYOBI batteries and need a durable, high-output tool for demanding tasks.
RIDGID 18V Subcompact Brushless One-Hand Reciprocating Saw
Best for: One-handed work in tight spaces
- Power Source
- 18V
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Included
- Tool only
- Tool Weight
- 3.9 pounds
- Tool Length
- 14.5 inches
- Included Tools
- Reciprocating Saw
View on Amazon: RIDGID 18V Subcompact Brushless One-Hand Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
The RIDGID R8648B is a bare-tool, 18V brushless reciprocating saw designed for one-handed use. It measures 14.5 inches long and weighs 3.9 pounds. The compact subcompact build helps you work in tight spaces. You get a brushless motor for efficiency. This tool is for users who already own compatible 18V batteries and need a lightweight option for demolition or pruning.
Pros
- Brushless motor for extended runtime
- Lightweight 3.9-pound design
- Compact 14.5-inch tool length
- One-handed operation capability
Cons
- Bare tool requires separate battery purchase
- Not eligible for Lifetime Service Agreement
- Single voltage platform limits cross-brand compatibility
Good fit if
- You need a lightweight saw for overhead or tight-space work
- You already own RIDGID 18V batteries
- You prioritize compact size over maximum power
Skip if
- You require a tool with a built-in battery
- You want a product covered by a Lifetime Service Agreement
- You need a 20V MAX or M18 system tool
Verdict: RIDGID 18V Brushless Subcompact Recip Saw fits users who already have 18V batteries and need a lightweight, compact tool for one-handed demolition tasks.
DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw
Best for: Users with existing 20V MAX batteries
- Power Source
- 20V MAX
- Stroke Length
- 1-1/8 in.
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Included
- Tool Only
- Blade Clamp
- Keyless, twist-style
- Variable Speed Trigger
- 2-finger variable trigger
View on Amazon: DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
The DEWALT DCS382B is a 20V MAX cordless reciprocating saw featuring a brushless motor for optimized efficiency. It includes a 1-1/8 inch stroke length for rapid cutting and a 2-finger variable trigger for speed control. The tool-only design offers seamless mobility with a compact size. It suits users needing a reliable, bare-tool option for demolition or construction tasks.
Pros
- Brushless motor provides optimized cutting power and efficiency
- 1-1/8 inch stroke length enables fast cuts
- 2-finger variable trigger allows precise speed control
- Twist-style keyless blade clamp ensures quick changes
Cons
- Sold as a bare tool with no battery included
- Lacks a dedicated belt clip or holster in the data
- No electronic features like Bluetooth or app connectivity
Good fit if
- You already own 20V MAX batteries
- You need a compact tool for tight spaces
- You prefer a twist-style keyless blade clamp
Skip if
- You need a complete kit with batteries and charger
- You require a 18V LXT system for compatibility
- You want a one-handed compact design for overhead work
Verdict: DEWALT DCS382B 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw fits contractors who already have 20V MAX batteries and need a compact, efficient tool for rapid demolition work.
DEWALT 20V MAX XR Compact Reciprocating Saw
Best for: tight spaces and dark areas
- Power Source
- 20V MAX XR
- Stroke Length
- 1-1/8"
- Strokes Per Minute
- up to 2,900 SPM
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Included
- Tool Only
- Tool Weight
- 5 lbs. (tool only)
View on Amazon: DEWALT 20V MAX XR Compact Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
This DEWALT reciprocating saw features a brushless motor and 20V MAX power source. It weighs 5 lbs and measures 14.5 inches long. The tool delivers up to 2,900 SPM with a 1-1/8 inch stroke. An LED light illuminates dark areas. It suits users needing a compact, lightweight saw for tight spaces and varied materials.
Pros
- Brushless motor for extended runtime
- Compact 14.5 inch length fits tight spots
- Built-in LED work light
- Keyless 4-position blade clamp
- Variable speed trigger up to 2,900 SPM
Cons
- Tool only; battery not included
- Heavier than subcompact alternatives
- No keyless chuck for quick bit changes
Good fit if
- You need a bright LED light for dark work areas
- You require a compact saw for tight spaces
- You prefer a brushless motor for longer runtime
Skip if
- You want a complete kit with batteries included
- You need a subcompact one-handed design
- You prioritize the lightest possible tool weight
Verdict: DEWALT 20V MAX XR Brushless Reciprocating Saw fits professionals who need a compact, bright, and versatile tool for tight spaces. It is ideal for those who already own 20V MAX batteries and value runtime and visibility.
Milwaukee M18 Fuel Brushless Reciprocating Saw
Best for: M18 users needing durability
- Power Source
- M18
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Included
- Bare tool only
- Tool Weight
- 6.8 pounds
- Tool Length
- 10 inches
- Blade Clamp
- Lever actuated
View on Amazon: Milwaukee M18 Fuel Brushless Reciprocating Saw Affiliate link
This Milwaukee M18 Fuel saw features a brushless motor and weighs 6.8 pounds. It measures 10 inches long with a lever-actuated blade clamp for quick changes. A built-in LED light illuminates your work surface. It is a bare tool, so you need an M18 battery. This model suits users who already own the Milwaukee M18 system and want a durable, heavy-duty saw.
Pros
- Brushless motor for efficiency
- Lever actuated blade clamp
- Built-in LED work light
- Metal reinforced battery connection
Cons
- Heavier at 6.8 pounds
- Bare tool only
- No variable speed trigger
Good fit if
- You use the M18 battery platform
- You prefer a lever clamp
- You need a durable build
Skip if
- You want a lighter tool
- You need a battery included
- You require variable speed control
Verdict: The Milwaukee M18 Fuel Brushless Reciprocating Saw is a solid choice for M18 users who prioritize durability and a secure blade clamp over lightweight handling.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Makita 18V LXT Brushless Reciprocating Saw | Makita 18V Brushless One-Handed Reciprocating Saw | RYOBI ONE+ HP 18V Brushless Reciprocating Saw | RIDGID 18V Subcompact Brushless One-Hand Reciprocating Saw | DEWALT 20V Brushless Reciprocating Saw | DEWALT 20V MAX XR Compact Reciprocating Saw | Milwaukee M18 Fuel Brushless Reciprocating Saw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power Source | 18V | 18V LXT | 18V Cordless | 18V | 20V MAX | 20V MAX XR | M18 |
| Stroke Length | 1-1/4" | 7/8 in. | 1-1/4" | not stated | 1-1/8 in. | 1-1/8" | not stated |
| Strokes Per Minute | 0-2, 300 (low) & 0-3, 000 (high) SPM | 0-3,100 SPM | 0-3,200 SPM | not stated | not stated | up to 2,900 SPM | not stated |
| Motor Type | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless |
| Battery Included | Tool only | Tool Only | Tool only | Tool only | Tool Only | Tool Only | Bare tool only |
| Tool Weight | 7.8 pounds | not stated | 7.2 pounds | 3.9 pounds | not stated | 5 lbs. (tool only) | 6.8 pounds |
| Tool Length | 17-1/4" | 14.4 inches | 19.2 inches | 14.5 inches | not stated | 14.5" | 10 inches |
| Blade Clamp | Tool-less | not stated | Tool-free blade release lever | not stated | Keyless, twist-style | Keyless 4-position blade clamp | Lever actuated |
| Variable Speed Trigger | Variable speed trigger | not stated | Variable speed trigger | not stated | 2-finger variable trigger | Variable speed trigger | not stated |
| Voltage | 18V | 18V | 18V | 18V | 20V | 20V | not stated |
| Included Tools | not stated | not stated | Reciprocating Saw | Reciprocating Saw | Reciprocating Saw | Work Light, Reciprocating Saw | Reciprocating Saw |
| Dimensions | 4.61 × 18.9 × 8.62 inches | 14.4 × 4 × 6 inches | 19.2 × 6.14 × 3.27 inches | 14.5 × 3 × 5.75 inches | not stated | 14.5 × 6 × 7 inches | 10 × 6 × 4 inches |
| Weight | 7.8 pounds | 1 pounds | 7.2 pounds | 3.9 pounds | not stated | 5.4 pounds | 6.8 pounds |
| Size | No Size | not stated | not stated | Not eligible for he Lifetime Service Agreement | not stated | One Size | not stated |
| Color | Multicolor | Teal | Green/Black | Ridgid Orange | Black | Black | Black |
| Model | XRJ05Z | XRJ08Z | PBLRS02B | R8648B | not stated | DCS367B | 2821-20 |
Looking beyond this list? See makita xbu03sm1 18v lxt lithium ion alternatives.
Frequently asked questions
Which reciprocating saw is best for one-handed use in tight spaces?
The Makita XRJ08Z and the RIDGID R8648B are designed for one-handed operation. The Makita model measures 14.4 inches long and weighs 1 pound with a battery. The RIDGID saw is slightly longer at 14.5 inches but weighs 3.9 pounds. Both tools allow you to work in confined areas where a standard saw cannot fit.
Can I use my existing Makita 18V batteries with these alternatives?
Yes, the Makita XRJ05Z, XRJ08Z, and RIDGID R8648B all operate on the 18V platform. The Makita models are part of the 18V LXT system. The RIDGID tool also uses 18V batteries. This compatibility allows you to share power sources across multiple tools in your workshop without needing separate charging stations.
What is the lightest reciprocating saw on this list?
The Makita XRJ08Z is the lightest option, weighing just 1 pound with a battery. The RIDGID R8648B is next at 3.9 pounds. The DEWALT DCS367B weighs 5.4 pounds. The Makita XRJ05Z is the heaviest at 7.8 pounds. Choosing a lighter tool reduces fatigue during extended overhead or one-handed cutting tasks.
Which saw includes a built-in work light?
The DEWALT DCS367B includes a built-in work light. This feature helps you see clearly in dark or tight spaces while cutting. Other models on the list do not list a work light in their included tools. If visibility is a priority for your demolition work, this DEWALT model offers that specific advantage.
Are all these tools brushless motor models?
Yes, every reciprocating saw listed features a brushless motor. The Makita XRJ05Z, XRJ08Z, RYOBI PBLRS02B, RIDGID R8648B, both DEWALT models, and the Milwaukee 2821-20 all use brushless technology. Brushless motors generally provide longer runtime and increased durability compared to brushed motors. This specification is consistent across all the recommended alternatives.
Which saw is best for users with a 20V battery ecosystem?
The DEWALT DCS382B and DCS367B are designed for the 20V MAX system. These tools require 20V batteries, not 18V ones. If you already own DEWALT 20V batteries, these saws will integrate seamlessly into your existing setup. The other options on the list use 18V batteries and are not compatible with 20V power sources.
How does the weight of the Milwaukee saw compare to the Makita XRJ05Z?
The Milwaukee 2821-20 weighs 6.8 pounds. The Makita XRJ05Z weighs 7.8 pounds. The Milwaukee tool is one pound lighter than the Makita standard model. Both are substantial tools for general cutting. The Milwaukee option offers a slightly more manageable weight for users who find the XRJ05Z too heavy for prolonged use.
Which reciprocating saw is the most compact in length?
The Milwaukee 2821-20 is the most compact, measuring only 10 inches in length. The Makita XRJ08Z and RIDGID R8648B are both around 14.5 inches long. The Makita XRJ05Z is longer at 18.9 inches. If you need the shortest possible tool for deep cuts or very confined areas, the Milwaukee model offers the smallest footprint.